Full Body Scanners, the Ineffective Way to Fight Terrorism

The United States Transportation Security Administration recently announced its intention of introducing up to 150 new full body scanners in airports. There’s been a lot of backlash from travelers and taxpayers regarding potential health concerns, costs, and time delays.  In light of this, there’s one other big question that needs answered. How effective will these machines be at eliminating the threat of terrorism on U.S. planes?

Do They Work?

Full body scanners either use x-rays or radio waves to view the first layer right under the clothes. Unlike, medical imaging instruments, they’re not designed to penetrate the skin. Do they do what they’re supposed to? The answer is yes. Unlike a metal detector, the scan can expose things hidden directly under clothes. 

The bigger question is whether it’s effective or not in terms of scanning for contraband? The problem is, the scan does not penetrate enough to be able to view body cavities and/or orifices. Even a large fold of fat on an obese person can be a place to hide objects from the device .Storing items in such places has been a long time favorite of drug smugglers. Don’t expect that to change with this new initiative and look for terrorists to take up the practice.

 Too Little

The full body scan simply will not deter the most dangerous terrorists.  Those groups that are well organized will have no problems getting around a simple system like this. Over time these scanners are likely to thwart a few threats of the mentally unstable variety but it’s likely that our most serious threats will see them as a minor obstacle in their path. 

Are there alternatives?

Some feel that the TSA may be jumping the gun by putting all of its money into body scanners. Currently, there are two other alternatives that have some merit. The TSA has tinkered with the “puffer” and the “guardian”. Both use chemicals to see if there are explosive devices on a person. The guardian can even detect substances in hard to monitor places like shoes. Of course, these devices have their own weaknesses, mostly around the maintenance of the machines.  Still, the TSA might want to save its money and see if either one is a viable option once improvements are made.

In conclusion one would find it very difficult to say that full body scanners will actually deter or prevent any terrorist attacks. For it to work a terrorist would have to be extremely illogical in his or her thought pattern to think that a weapon or bomb could be smuggled right under their clothes.  It’s highly unlikely that the initiative will make any real dent in serious terrorist activities. As such, a better path would probably be to spend the funds on more worthwhile efforts such as intelligence.

 

 

Related News Articles

Raspberry Pi 3D full-body scanner interview
Sat, 19 Jul 2014 18:29:44 -0700
LinuxUser: We talk to Richard Garsthagen about why he needs 40 Raspberry Pis to take a picture of you

TSA heightening security on cellphones and laptops
Sun, 06 Jul 2014 15:11:43 -0700
Travelers flying directly to the United States from overseas are being asked to turn on their cellphones and laptops before boarding their aircraft, officials said Sunday. The security measure calls...

3D printed models - the family portraits of the future
Sun, 29 Jun 2014 19:38:54 -0700
The Hodgkinson family discover the joys of the world's first high-speed 3D full body scanner at a giant Asda store in Manchester.

Scanner: Pricey Pelé
Sat, 28 Jun 2014 23:31:46 -0700
OSIM India has launched uShape, a full-body vibration exercise machine. It claims to increase muscle strength, flexibility and blood circulation and help the body burn up to 136 calories in 10 minutes. It also claims to offer users the flexibility to customise their workouts.

Full-body scanners may replace some genital searches at Guantanamo
Tue, 08 Jul 2014 12:41:15 -0700
Giving new meaning to the military’s motto of transparent detention, the Guantánamo Bay war-on-terror prison is shopping for devices to conduct full-body scans at its outpost in southeast Cuba.

Will full-body scanners replace some genital searches at Guantanamo?
Tue, 08 Jul 2014 14:55:07 -0700
Giving new meaning to the military’s motto of transparent detention, the Guantánamo Bay war-on-terror prison is shopping for devices to conduct full-body scans at its outpost in southeast Cuba.

Med students in Australia use 3D printed body parts in place of cadavers for research
Wed, 16 Jul 2014 13:29:44 -0700
The zombie apocalypse isn’t the only factor driving up the demand for dead bodies. More medical students + people living longer = fewer cadavers for scientific research and medical education....

Mammoth secrets revealed by scan
Fri, 18 Jul 2014 03:17:17 -0700
Newly released 3-D images of two mummified baby mammoths provide a window into the lives of creatures that roamed Siberia 40,000 years ago.

Here’s What You Learn When You Put a Baby Mammoth in a 3-D Scanner
Tue, 08 Jul 2014 17:16:48 -0700
A new paper gives insight into the early life and premature death of two baby mammoths.

US panicked by ‘undetectable’ bombs
Sun, 06 Jul 2014 15:14:02 -0700
The US Transportation Security Administration (TSA) has introduced new enhanced security measures at overseas airports with direct flights to the United States.

Los Angeles International LAX | Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International ATL | Chicago O'Hare International ORD | Dallas/Fort Worth International DFW | Denver International Airport DEN | Las Vegas McCarran International LAS | John F. Kennedy International Airport JFK | Phoenix Sky Harbor International PHX | Houston George Bush Intercontinental IAH | Newark Liberty International EWR | Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County DTW | Minneapolis-Saint Paul International MSP | Orlando International MCO | San Francisco International SFO | Miami International MIA | Philadelphia International PHL | Charlotte/Douglas International CLT | Seattle-Tacoma International SEA | Boston Logan International BOS | New York City LaGuardia LGA | Washington Dulles International IAD | Baltimore-Washington International Thurgood Marshall BWI | Salt Lake City International SLC | Fort Lauderdale-Hollywood International FLL | Honolulu International HNL | Tampa International TPA | Ronald Reagan Washington National DCA | Chicago Midway International MDW | San Diego International SAN | Cincinnati/Northern Kentucky International CVG | Oakland International OAK | Lambert-St. Louis International STL | Portland International PDX | Memphis International MEM | Kansas City International MCI | Cleveland Hopkins International CLE | San Jose International SJC | Sacramento International SMF | Pittsburgh International PIT | Nashville International BNA | Orange County John Wayne Airport SNA | Raleigh-Durham International RDU | Houston William P. Hobby Airport HOU | Indianapolis International IND | Austin-Bergstrom International AUS | San Antonio International SAT | Fort Myers Southwest Florida International RSW | Milwaukee General Mitchell International MKE | Dallas Love Field DAL | Palm Beach International PBI | Hartford - Springfield Bradley International BDL | LA/Ontario International ONT | Port Columbus International CMH | Albuquerque International ABQ | Louis Armstrong New Orleans International MSY | Kahului Airport OGG | Jacksonville International JAX | Burbank Bob Hope Airport BUR | Providence Theodore Francis Green Airport PVD | Reno-Tahoe International RNO | Ted Stevens Anchorage International ANC | Tucson International TUS | Omaha Eppley Airfield OMA | Manchester-Boston Regional MHT | Norfolk International ORF | Louisville International SDF | Oklahoma City Will Rogers World Airport OKC | El Paso International ELP | Boise Airport BOI | Richmond International RIC | Spokane International GEG | Tulsa International TUL | Birmingham-Shuttlesworth International BHM | Kona International KOA | Albany International ALB | Greater Rochester International ROC | Agana Antonio B. Won Pat International GUM | Long Beach Airport LGB | Lihue Airport LIH | Dayton International DAY | Little Rock National LIT | Islip Long Island MacArthur Airport ISP | Syracuse Hancock International SYR | Greensboro Piedmont Triad International GSO | Grand Rapids Gerald R. Ford International GRR | Colorado Springs Airport COS | Savannah/Hilton Head International SAV | Des Moines International DSM | Charleston International CHS | Orlando Sanford International SFB | Springfield-Branson National SGF | Knoxville McGhee Tyson Airport TYS | Pensacola Regional Airport PNS | Madison Dane County Regional Airport MSN | Palm Springs International PSP | Greenville-Spartanburg International GSP | Jackson-Evers International JAN | Huntsville International HSV | Wichita Mid-Continent Airport ICT | Buffalo Niagara International BUF